Miss a day, miss a lot. Subscribe to The Defender's Top News of the Day. It's free.
But according to Wayne Rohde, an expert in vaccine injury compensation, the requested 15% increase which does not involve new tax dollars, is routine.
What’s more interesting, Rohde told The Defender, is that the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) budget for COVID- 19 vaccine injury compensation will increase in fiscal year 2023 — from approximately $1 million to $5 million — and its budget for staffing and contractors will jump from $5 million to $9.5 million.
Rohde, author of “The Vaccine Court 2.0,” co-founder of Vaccine Safety Council of Minnesota and Autism Advocacy Coalition of Minnesota, and national advisory member of Health Choice, said he learned of the increase through information he obtained under the Freedom of Information Act.
HRSA, which operates under the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), administers two vaccine injury compensation programs: the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP) and the Countermeasures Injury Compensation Program (CICP).
The VICP is a special, no-fault tribunal housed within the U.S. Court of Federal Claims that handles injury claims for 16 common vaccines. To date, it has awarded more than $4 billion to thousands of people for vaccine injuries.
The VICP does not cover COVID-19 vaccine injuries — those are covered under the Countermeasures Injury Compensation Program (CICP), established under the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness (PREP) Act.
The funding mechanisms for the two programs are different. Funding for the VICP comes from the Vaccine Injury Trust Fund. Congress must appropriate money out of this fund to the three coordinating federal agencies: HRSA, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) Torts Branch and Federal Claims Court, where all petitions are litigated. This is done on an annual basis.
To fund the CICP, HRSA and HHS must ask Congress for any additional funding to cover expansion of the staffing needed to administer the program. Rohde learned through his FOIA request that HRSA has contracted with several private companies to provide logistical support, petition processing and communications for CICP.
What happens when the PREP Act expires, which it is set to do in March 2024? It’s possible that COVID-19 vaccine injuries could then be covered under the VICP. However, it’s unclear at this point if that’s what will happen.
Meanwhile, only about 8% of the people who applied to the CICP with vaccine injuries in the past have ever received payouts and there are no protections from the U.S. legal system.
Between 2010 and December 2022, 11,431 claims were filed with the CICP — 10,899 of those claims for injuries were for COVID-19 vaccine and countermeasures, including testing and treatment.
Of the 10,899 COVID-19 countermeasure claims, 7,624 allege injuries/deaths from COVID-19 vaccines and 3,275 allege injuries/deaths from other COVID-19 countermeasures.
None of the 10,899 COVID-19 countermeasure claims has been fully compensated, according to Rohde, who said 10 of the claims were approved for compensation, but upon review were denied.
Once again, HRSA publishes COVID related compensation petitions. Dec 2022 data. 10,899 petitions. Still not one case has been fully comp. 10 claims were eligible but after a review of medical exp or lost employment income, no such luck for the injured. This is really pathetic. pic.twitter.com/3nTW9hGG5t
— Wayne Rohde (@waynerohde) December 17, 2022
15% increase in spending bill ‘not new money’
Rep. Dan Bishop (R-N.C.) called out the 15% funding increase contained in the spending bill, Newsweek reported.
“Anticipating a 15% increase in vaccine injuries?” Bishop asked in a series of tweets critiquing the contents of the bill.
Last year’s administrative expenses for the vax injury trust fund were $13.2 million – now it’s $15.2 million.
That’s a 15% increase. Anticipating a 15% increase in vaccine injuries?
It also authorizes “sums as may be necessary” for vaccine injury/death claims. pic.twitter.com/HtoUnniRxt
— Rep. Dan Bishop (@RepDanBishop) December 20, 2022
But according to Rohde, the 15% increase appropriated in the bill is not necessarily new money. Rohde said the spending bill provides $15.2 million for administrative expenses for the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program Trust Fund, which funds the VICP.
Each year, Congress appropriates from the trust fund to pay for the administrative expenses of each of the three federal agencies involved (HRSA, DOJ and the federal claims court). Each year, those agencies request an increase in their budget for the upcoming year, Rohde said.
According to the vaccine-injured, the VICP has failed miserably as a litigious, broken system that pits them against well-funded government programs, agencies and health officials.
Payouts, including attorneys’ fees, are funded by a 75-cent tax per vaccine and there’s a $250,000 cap on pain and suffering. The proceedings are often turned into drawn-out, contentious expert battles and the backlog of cases is substantial.
‘This is a mess’
The HRSA budget increase discovered by Rohde anticipates an increase in claims, but it does not come close to what would be necessary to compensate the vaccine-injured, Rohde told The Defender.
“What we haven’t seen, and I’ve been looking for, is whether they are going to create a fund to pay for covid injuries,” he said. “There is no trust fund to pay for COVID-19 vaccine injuries like there is for traditional vaccines, there is no funding mechanism.”
According to Rohde, the VICP is already understaffed and underfunded. He estimated that when the PREP Act expires, if COVID-19 vaccines are added to the VICP, they would need an additional appropriation of $30-40 million dollars just to cover the court costs — not including funding necessary for the DOJ and for HRSA.
“This is a mess that is going to be interesting to figure out,” he said.
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1,469,237 reports of adverse events following the COVID-19 vaccines were submitted between Dec. 14, 2020, and Dec. 9, 2022, to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS).
UPDATED: This article was updated to clarify the two different funding mechanisms for the VICP, which processes vaccine injury claims other than those related to COVID-19, and the CICP, which processes claims for COVID-19 vaccine injuries.